When another author who's posted work on HarperCollins'
Authonomy in hopes of winning her way onto the "Editor's Desk" for a shot at an HC publishing contract asked how many of us thought the site resembled the
Survivor TV show, I wondered how far any of us would go to "win."
Book-length manuscripts posted on the site advance to the "Editor's Desk" when they are backed (as worthy) by authors on the site. While contestants on
Survivor win by voting each other off the island, Authonomy authors don't have buttons that lower each other's scores or kick books out of the running altogether.
But if we did have such a button, would we push it? "Winning" on Authonomy brings with it no guarantees other than a look and a comment from an HC editor. There are no cash prizes and certainly no promises of a publishing contract with HC. To my knowledge, none the monthly winners have been published by HC.
Short of getting to the Authonomy "Editor's Desk," the only other way to get your manuscript in front of a HarperCollins editor is through an agent. And agents know that HC doesn't consider manuscripts unless they're likely to sell a minimum of 50,000 books.
As I wondered how many authors there would push a button to knock another book off the site, I couldn't help but think of the well-known
Milgram experiment back in the 1960s that explored whether or not subjects would administer electric shocks to others when told to do so by an authority figure. The subjects didn't know that those purportedly getting the shocks were actors. A fair number of people in the survey were willing to push the button.
On the
Survivor program, the stakes are high: $1,000,000. For an author trying to get HarperCollins' attention, the states are also high: a prospective contract with one of the top five publishers in the country along with fame, fortune and a jump start to a very difficult career to break into. Would you push the button?
I can hear the rationalizations already: "He said something nasty about my book?" "Her manuscript is full of errors." "His book isn't bad, but it had more than the average number of sluts in it." "My book is about important themes, and those other books are just chick lit."
As I wonder just how we might act if Authonomy were set up exactly like
Survivor, I'm not sure desperate authors would behave as well as we think we would. Sobering thoughts on this cold Georgia morning.
Copyright (c) 2009 by
Malcolm R. Campbell